卢米斯查菲学校:美国寄宿高中的教学法跟大学是一样的。我得知中国有些学校的班级人数多达59人,这在美国寄宿高中时难以想象的。我们一般最多只有14个人,因为我们希望同学们能够更多参与课堂讨论。美国的大学十分看重同学们独立思考的能力,因为大学毕业后,你需要自己做决定。美国寄宿高中十分注重培养同学们的批判性思维能力,为他们未来做好准备。
巴克夏中学:我们每年度都有一次赞助活动。
布莱尔学院:不管学生来自哪里,只要你在我们学校,都是需要赞助的,付学费也是一部分,不是吗?
卢米斯查菲学校:每个学校的学生背景都十分多样,有些同学的确是捐款进入的。每年我们会提供930万美金的助学金。我们每年大概会收到300万的募捐,大部分来自于学生家长和校友。这些赞助使得我们学校的学生遍布美国各大州以及40多个国家。我们学校的跑道甚至比新英格兰地区很多大学的跑道都要好。
北野山中学:这个问题可以换个角度:我作为家长该怎么融入美高?最简单的答案就是除了学费之外,在经济上多些贡献。我们会询问是否有国内以及国外的家庭愿意接待新同学,并且分享他们的孩子在我校学习生活的故事。我们十分重视学校的口碑。接待新同学或者别的市场活动对我们真的非常重要。
泰博学院:有时候我们会带一群学生来北京或者上海旅行,如果当地的家庭愿意招待这些学生,请他们吃晚饭,我们将十分感激!
Our Distinguished Guest Speakers answered some tough questions about boarding school admissions and the Chinese landscape. No holds were barred in this exclusive media interview. Our speakers bristled at the Chinese focus on rankings and the Ivy Leagues while also speaking honestly about donations in regards to Chinese students and boarding schools. Our host started with some easy questions before diving into some sticky questions that represented the most common questions from Chinese parents that are often left unasked. What are your testing requirements?
NMH: 95+ for TOEFL; for 10th graders 105+
Tabor: We do not have a set minimum; average is 105. We do look at students in the mid-90s, but this is a case by case basis.
Concord: We do not have a minimum SSAT or TOEFL; our average TOEFL is 105; we do not offer any formal English Language support. For the SSAT, an 84th percentile is our average, but it is generally higher for Chinese students.
Miss Porters: The average TOEFL is 105 and the average SSAT is between 75 and 80, but the average for Chinese students is much higher.
Are there are advantages for Chinese students studying in American middle schools versus remaining in China?
Berkshire: The advantage for students studying in US junior boarding schools is that they come with an understanding of the challenges they face. staying away for a year
Tabor: The admission office is able to know that the student can handle the entire spectrum of boarding school life for those who come from junior boarding schools. However, the advantages are not so great that a student coming from mainland without the junior boarding experience does not have a shot at our schools.
Concord: We know that there are so many different types of schools and there are schools like Nanjing Foreign Language that offer a community like Concord and we have support systems in place to help support them. We know that students coming out of these environments can do just as well as students receiving an education in a US middle school.
Loomis: The American boarding schools teach in same pedagogical style as universities do. I was talking to students today who said that their classes are 59 students. That doesn’t happen at US boarding schools. Our biology classes have about 14 students at most. Students are expected to bring a lot more to the class. In American colleges, you need to produce things – they are asking for your opinions and perspectives. After college you need to make decisions. We do a lot of critical thinking work in US boarding schools so that students feel comfortable and can make good decisions in college and beyond.
What makes a student stand out in your eyes as someone you want to bring to your school?
NMH: We want to make sure students are bringing their true selves; I want to see what you are passionate about. I want to see 1-2 things you’ve taken and gone deeply into. It’s about understanding what the student wants and describing to us the challenges they face in their school and how they have overcome those challenges.
Tabor: We interview 1000 students or more. Answers that sound rehearsed or practiced make it difficult for us to get to know who the child is and if the student can be a student at the school. We want to see who the child is not what they think we want to hear
Loomis: I was talking to a student in 5th grade. When I asked him about what kinds of things he liked to do outside of class, he talked about computers – all I could get was ‘computers’ and I couldn’t get a sense of what he liked to do with them.
When I asked about what he liked to do in his free time, he started talking about books and he was able to explain that he likes Artemis Fowl and CS Lewis and Lord of the Rings. When we got off script we had a great conversation.
Miss Porter’s: Students need to have some sense of why this school is the school for them. The student needs to be able to articulate that at some level when they come to our interview.
Can the parents’ interview help the students? Is it necessary for parents to attend the interviews?
Blair: It’s really important for at least one of the parents to be there. It is more helpful for both to be there. We interview the parents separately from the students.
Tabor: We want to help understand the child through the parents. For introverted kids, we try to get to know the kids through the parents. We want to know who that kids is and can be.
Miss Porter’s: Once the student comes to the school, the relationship with the family becomes one of the most important aspects of that student’s experience there. We want to have an understanding of their family relationship and help us to connect with the student in the same way that the parents do. It is important for the future of the school.
Is it necessary for students to find a consulting firm to help I their applications?
NMH: I think the consultants are a huge part of it. They can play a big role in helping students navigate a very complicated process. Developing the relationship with the consultants is very important for us in admissions. It is important for us to know who these students are working with. Us knowing the company is very important so that I can contact them to learn more about the student and the family because it is about finding the best fit for a student and that way I can refer students to other schools as well.
Loomis: The consultants are best for those who feel unfamiliar with the territory. Consultants can help to narrow things down.
Concord: We don’t require consultants in order to apply. That said, it can be to your advantage because there are so many great schools out there and the consultant gets to know your child, your family, their interests, your interests and they can select schools for your child and that is invaluable. We know which partners are trusted in international education. There are ones we like and ones we don’t like.
As you know, Chinese parents value rankings very much. What do you think of the ranking of your school?
Tabor: The boarding school rankings are not that great right now. At the boarding school level there still isn’t much of a strong ranking.
Blair: When you look at the rankings, you need to know who is making the rankings. Look at what they are measuring – if all you care about is how many students get into Ivy league colleges then that’s easy, but to say one school is better than the other, I don’t know that anyone can really defend that. We don’t know exactly what they are measuring –someone is usually trying to make money.
Chinese parents hope their children will get into Ivy League schools? What can you do to help at boarding schools?
Blair: The Ivy League is an athletic conference; all those schools are grouped together because they play sports against each other. There are many schools not in the Ivy league that are the equal or better. You should look at where students are going for graduate schools. Top graduate schools are taking students from a much wider range than just Ivy Leagues.
Miss Porter’s: The goal is not to get into Ivy League schools. It is to prepare students to succeed in their best fit college. It’s not about ranking, but about fit.
Loomis: We do two things for students who want to pursue a school of that level: we challenge them and we will give them the support to master that challenge to create a profile that an elite school would seek. If you think about 10 years ago how many students were studying in the US, it was much lower; My wife and I both choose to go to a non-Ivy and turned down acceptances from Ivy Leagues. As the Chinese population becomes more knowledgeable about all elite schools in the US, this perspective of Ivy League or bust will go away.
Blair: The best Chinese student we have this year is going to Swarthmore and that is his choice. Students below him are going to Columbia and Cornell.
NMH: The term Ivy League means selectivity. Swarthmore is a very selective school; Amherst, Williams, UChicago. As Chinese families become more knowledgeable, they start to ask themselves about the selectivity. These Ivy Leagues are going to select whoever they want whenever they want. A certain GPA and test score does not get you into a selective school. We can’t guarantee a Stanford or an Ivy League. It goes back to fit and that is what we aim to establish and accomplish with each of our students.
Tabor: This year we had 4 students turn down Ivy League schools to go to other schools – these kids know they will be challenged, happy, and having a transformative experience – it’s about success.
Concord: I’m Chinese American and my parents wanted me to go to boarding school and then Harvard. When I told them that I refused to apply to Ivy League colleges, it led to some tough conversations. I didn't even apply to Harvard, but as I was going through my college counseling process, I worked with my parents and college counselor to come up with a list. I went to Wellesley. I was so happy while it wasn’t even on my parents’ radar. Parents want students to go to schools that other parents will recognize. Parents will start to recognize more and more names as more Chinese students attend schools in the US.
How can boarding schools help young Chinese students acclimate and overcome culture shock?
Tabor: It’s not young Chinese students who have culture shock. It’s all students. It’s our goal to help students make friends, go out and have fun.
Berkshire: When I go home tomorrow, my thoughts are on August and how I can welcome the 100 new students we will have coming to campus.
Loomis: Pragmatically, this is how we help Chinese students acclimate. A Chinese student comes to Loomis two days early for an international orientation. In the fall of their first year, new students are required to be on a team (they don’t have to be great athletes), but it gives them another group. If kids are struggling with homesickness, we have student leaders in the dorm they can go to; kids can also go to a dorm parent (3-4 faculty parents in each dorm). Students can go to the apartment and pet the dog. There are peer counselors – other students trained to be good listeners. They can identify if the student needs an adult counselor. We have international coordinators. At my school, the kids are really open and so aware of when others’ are struggling, and they try to step in and help.
Tabor: sometimes the homesickness is more difficult for the parents than for the students. Parents are so used to having the kids around and the mystery is nerve-wracking. Parents are their child’s first go to for support. If anything bad happens, a child needs to talk to their parents to get it out. After the conversation, the kid is fine and the trouble is gone, but then the parents call me and are so worried. They tell me the kid is struggling so much and please go check on him and so I got out and check on the kid and he is as happy as can be - watching TV, playing games in the dorm. Some of it is the parents learning how to manage not having their kids around.
Some people think parents should be there for the students during important periods. It could be considered irresponsible to send them so far away – what are your thoughts?
Loomis: It depends on the student and what they need. My wife’s sister has 3 daughters and the oldest went to Loomis – the other two wouldn’t have left home no matter what, but the oldest was done with her hometown at 15. For her, that was the absolute right move. I think it would be irresponsible for a parent to force the child to go somewhere if they don't want to. That is not a good choice, but it’s not right to say in the abstract that sending any child away at 14 is irresponsible.
Blair: I have 3 siblings. I went to a small private day school. Two of my siblings went to a big public high school. Once of my siblings went to Choate. We all wound up at Cornell. My parents knew that we all needed different schools and experiences.
Miss Porter’s: My 12 year old is already asking to go away. All kids have a different level of connection to their families. My son is already ready to go whereas my daughter would not be willing to leave.
If the student is studying in your school, do the parents need to donate?Berkshire: We have an annual fund and fundraisers all the time.Blair: Regardless of from China or anywhere else, if your student is at school we will ask for money.Loomis: When you think about the diversity of schools, part of that comes from the largesse of those who donate. We give out 9.3 million dollars a year in financial aid. We do raise 3 million dollars a year in annual funds – money given to the school; a lot of it given by parents and alums. Money allows us to have kids from 40 countries and all the states. My track is better than half the colleges in New England. It’s an 8-lane super-highway.NMH: The question that we want all parents to ask and answer for themselves is: how can I as a parent be involved? The easy answer is to contribute financially outside of tuition, but we ask both domestic and international families to help host receptions for new students. The word of mouth within countries and cities is huge. Providing story lines for how their kids are doing is very important for us because we value our reputation. Holding receptions and other kinds of marketing is really important for us.Tabor: we will take a group of kids and travel in Beijing and Shanghai and sometimes a local family will host those students for a dinner and that is a huge help for us.